As few in the City knew him, his appointment was given a lukewarm reception. But the first clues to his talent came in the bad-tempered reaction of Kingfisher's Sir Geoff Mulcahy when Holmes handed in his notice. Indeed, so upset was Mulcahy - and those early City profiles, conducted in Kingfisher time, did not help - that he initially threatened to hold Holmes to a very long notice period. Although Mulcahy had been keeping it quiet (no change there) he had secretly been lining up the new M&S man as his own heir apparent.