Venison was dropped after the programme initially failed to bring in the viewers.
Now Logan will be ITV's main footballer presenter from next season, taking over on Champions League live games from Des Lynam who will present his last match at the Euro 2004 championships before pursuing other projects.
She has a six-figure deal as ITV's main sports presenter after reports of a bidding war with the BBC.
Logan is the first woman to hold the top job. A spokesman said: "Gabby will be the main sports presenter from next season - she will be the first lady of football.
"ITV will have two Champions League matches on Tuesdays and Gabby will present ITV1's coverage, while Matt Smith will present for ITV2."
Next year Logan will also present the coverage of the Oxford and Cambridge university boat race after ITV won the rights ahead of the BBC.
She is the daughter of former Leeds and Wales footballer Terry Yorath and her husband is the Scottish rugby international, Kenny Logan.
She once said: "I learned about football the way children learn to speak. For me it seems completely natural to be involved in football because I have been all my life."