Giggs on Sunday at the City of Manchester Stadium endured as painful an afternoon as he will have remembered. United were trailing 3-1 with 14 minutes left and needing goals quickly when Giggs - captain for the day - was substituted. A bad end to a very bad day. Though the Welshman continues to produce football that would see him fit comfortably into most Premiership teams, it is a long time since he managed to contribute consistent, match-winning performances.