Speaking about Small Island, the judges said: 'What could have been a didactic or preachy prospect turns out to be hilarious, moving human and eye-popping. It's hard to think of anybody not enjoying it.' With Miss Levy taking best novel, women writers have three out of the top five Whitbread awards. The first novel award went to Susan Fletcher for Eve Green - a coming-of-age story about an orphaned eight-year-old girl who leaves her Birmingham home to live with her grandparents in rural Wales.