Cornwell is obviously fervently opposed to capital punishment. Two scenes in the book, describing, with a wealth of well-researched detail, public hangings at Newgate, are extremely powerful, even stomach-churning: no wonder that Sir Henry Forrest, witnessing, in his official capacity as an alderman, an execution for the first time, cannot look forward to enjoying the devilled kidneys that are - as we are told eight times in the course of the book - traditionally served to visitors after the event. But these scenes sit oddly with - indeed, their effect is to some extent undermined by - the tone of jokey sentimentality that pervades the rest of the narrative: itself not much more than Sharpe and water. Though, as always, Cornwell keeps one turning the pages at light infantry pace.