There is, however, no single story: each group has its own struggle. In the South of France, old ladies still use ProvenÁal as a secret language, most commonly as a tool for shameless gossip. The problems for the Sami - who, like the older residents of Provence, remember being beaten at school for speaking their indigenous language - are more deep-rooted: loss not only of language, but of land and culture, too. One subset of Sami is spoken now by only eight people. "How lonely they must feel," writes Drysdale, "condemned forever to be foreigners in their own land, and knowing that with their death will die a way of communicating, a repository of collective memory."