Which? also tested 11 standard sunscreens to see if they offered the SPF30 they claimed.
All but one passed the test but the watchdog warned people against using Hawaiian Tropic Satin Protection Ultra Radiance Lotion SPF30 (180ml) as it said the product offered “significantly less” than its claimed SPF.
Which? said the company told the campaign group it had conducted its own tests and was “confident” in its results.
A Hawaiian Tropic spokesman said: "We are confident in our test results which consistently indicate year over year that our SPF 30 products in fact exceed the label claim & EU requirements, even after 80 minutes in the water."
The results show budget own-brand sunscreens from Asda, Lidl and Wilko all to offer the SPF claimed when tested, busting any assertion cheaper products are less safe.