Clash of the 4X4s: Land Rover Defender v Mercedes G-Class

Still the Mercedes G-Class can’t shake off being challenged by the Land Rover Defender…
1/12
Rob Adams|Autocar
2 March 2017

The Mercedes G-Wagen is a must-have fashion accessory. The Land Rover Defender is dead. Did the British firm jump too soon? After all, with everything from six-wheeled offshoots to monster AMG-tuned models, there seems to be no end to what you can do to a G-Class. Land Rover never really indulged here. Could it have milked the Defender in the same profitable way?

Over to Thirsk-based Twisted, an aftermarket tuner that reckons it has created just the thing to go head-to-head with a G-Wagen: the Twisted Defender 110 T40. Resplendent in posh Aintree Green, we’ll be driving that off-road later. First, Twisted boss Charlie Fawcett shows us the firm’s Defender 90 T40S, so we can see just how far you can go with a Twisted.

This was once a £30,000 Defender XS. It’s now a £90,000 Defender style icon, with five pages of modifications and umpteen hours’ engineering. It takes a full 30 hours to install all the soundproofing. Custom Bilstein dampers and Eibach springs have been painstakingly tuned. Even the rattly 2.2-litre diesel engine has been updated to make it more exploitable.

They can’t transform the Defender into something approaching modernity – the G-Class does that better – but they do make it much more tolerable in daily driving, so you can appreciate its character, rather than simply be annoyed by it.

That’s a car of two sides. On one hand, you have a modern 3.0-litre V6 turbodiesel and fancy 7G-Trionic gearbox, plus leather, sat nav, rear entertainment screens and all sorts of other luxuries. But on the other, you get in using a weighty door latch that clicks just like something from the 1970s, exposing period vinyl door cards and pure functionality.

On the road, it feels more tank-like than any modern car, and a damn sight more narrow than we’re used to. Thin windscreen pillars mean you can easily see out, while light steering and a helpful auto are sophisticated, and the wonderful V6 engine’s creamy pull makes light work of a 2.6-tonne kerbweight. Only the shudders and thuds over some bumps really betray its dated roots.

It’s a bit compromised at speed, with vague steering and an unwillingness to pile into bends. But it’s still capable, and is outstanding off-road with its hilariously over-specced four-wheel drive running gear. There are diff lock buttons all over the dash, a low range gearbox, enough ability to easily cope with anything you might dare drive over. In the wilderness, it too is a delight.

With this pairing, we’ve proven a point. Twisted is facing crazy demand for its hyper-priced Defenders, showing that Land Rover may well have missed a trick in not doing with the Defender what Mercedes has done with the G-Wagen. Sure, it’s a crude beast alongside the Merc, but it’s loveable with it, and you can’t help but think that, with a bit of development, the Landie could now be enjoying the same celebrity adulation Mercedes is now savouring with the G. Ah, what could have been…

MERCEDES-BENZ G350D

Engine: 2,987cc V6 diesel
Transmission: 7-speed auto, low-range transfer case, four-wheel drive
Power (hp): 245@3,600rpm
Torque (lb ft): 442@1,600-2,400rpm
0-62mph: 8.9 seconds
Top speed: 119mph
Weight: 2,612kg
MPG: 28.5 (NEDC combined)
CO2: 261g/km
Price: £88,800 (£102,233 as tested)

TWISTED DEFENDER 110 T40

Engine: 2,198cc 4-cyl turbodiesel
Transmission: 6-speed manual with low-range transfer case, 4WD
Power (hp): 122@3,500rpm (170hp with P4 performance upgrade; Twisted figure)
Torque (lb ft): 265@2,000rpm (standard)
0-62mph: 15.8sec
Top speed: 90mph
Weight: c. 1,902kg (with fluids and driver)
MPG: N/A
CO2: 266g/km (110 295g/km)
Price: £63,474 as tested (inc. VAT)

(All stats for standard car before modification unless otherwise stated)

Follow Evening Standard Motors on Twitter and Facebook.

MORE ABOUT