Shaun Brady, 41, was sacked in the wake of a brawl at a barbecue in May where he clashed with union president Martin Samways, who has since resigned. The two ended up in a flowerbed and a member of staff, Julie Atkinson, was struck in the mouth. But Mr Brady was dismissed not for the barbecue incident but because he was found guilty by the union's Left-wing dominated executive committee of failing to cooperate with an inquiry into Aslef and its finances by Matthias Kelly QC.