Yet research for Financial Mail reveals that despite praise heaped on these titans of industry, the best returns for shareholders over the past five years have been produced by the lesser lights of the FTSE 100. Since the crash of 2000, investors have sought solace in beer and cigarettes, making Ted Tuppen, boss of Enterprise Inns, top of the league for shareholder value with a 482% return, according to the figures from financial information group Hemscott.