Wholesale banking has been habitually troublesome for Abbey. Last autumn, it admitted that, yes, the division did indeed face problems. The redoubtable Gareth Jones - credited with building the division virtually from scratch - left amid rumours of disagreements over strategy. Shortly afterwards, Abbey disclosed a £95m loss on loans to bankrupt energy giant Enron, and wrote off a further £150m against the collapse in value of its high risk, junk bond investments. But Harley insisted there were no undisclosed black holes. Six weeks ago, he said Abbey's trading as a whole was in line with forecasts.