Old hands will rightly say that this sort of chicanery always comes to light in a bear market. Nonetheless, the extent to which public confidence in the financial system has been shaken is alarming. The Dow Jones index of leading US shares has struggled to return to its value before 11 September. Over the past month, it has dipped back sharply as investors, spooked by each fresh set of revelations, are left scratching their heads over how much shares are really worth.