As citizens, we have become subject to ever greater monitoring, surveillance and intrusion. Yesterday Andy Burnham, the Culture Secretary, said he was "staggered" by my criticisms of CCTV, claiming it is vital for fighting crime and counter-terrorism. I am not against all CCTV. But the current approach is just daft. This Government has spent about half a billion pounds on CCTV - we have more cameras than any other country in the world, one for every 14 citizens. Yet the police say 80 per cent of CCTV footage is of poor quality, particularly for identifying criminals. Mr Burnham mentioned the role of CCTV in identifying the 21/7 bombers. But after the shooting of Jean Charles de Menezes there was no usable footage from any of the CCTV cameras on the bus, Tube or at Stockwell station.