My gazpacho was refreshing, pleasantly stinging with sherry vinegar and garlic and elegantly thin. Amy's chilled watercress soup was, I felt, not correct, being thick with lots of potato - I prefer it green, smooth and clean. Amy liked it, though. William went for the tomato and mozzarella and the tomatoes were red and full of flavour. Our fourth diner, who did not want to be named, chose chicken liver pate. It was a slice of pure Seventies style straight from Mummy's larder with a dash of sherry - fine straightforward eating, except it was too cold. It came with triangles of sliced granary bread, crusts off.