Our Oscars 2023 verdict: did the best films win?

From Everything Everywhere to Banshees’ award disappointment
TOPSHOT-US-ENTERTAINMENT-FILM-AWARD-OSCARS-PRESSROOM
AFP via Getty Images
Charlotte O'Sullivan
13 March 2023

Everything deserved Everything — and got it.

Yeoh deservedly made history

I remember watching the Malaysian actress in Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon and thinking, “She’s cool. What a shame her character gets sidelined!” I never thought Yeoh, at 60, would become the first Asian woman to win a Best Actress Oscar.

Fraser’s Whale should have been harpooned

And the award for best hyperactive eyebrow wiggling goes to... Brendan Fraser. Poor guy. You can see, in The Whale’s opening 10 minutes, what he’s capable of as the obese shut-in professor, but he can’t rise above the bargain-basement theatrics that follow. Did he deserve to beat Colin Farrell, Austin Butler or Paul Mescal? No, he did not. What use is it to viewers that the 54-year-old former heart-throb has a gripping backstory? Both he and EEAAO’s Ke Huy Quan have one of those. But Quan has that narrative IRL, after disappearing from screens after The Goonies, and, playing Waymond Wang, he consistently dazzles on screen. We’ll be celebrating Waymond for years to come. The Whale’s Charlie, not so much.

A wail for the Banshees

In case you hadn’t noticed, The Banshees of Inisherin and The Quiet Girl came away with nothing. There was much talk about the “great green wave”, but the takeover vanished into thin air. Nach mór an trua é. That’s Irish for “rats!”