Numis said the decision was an “interesting move and in our view very sensible”, noting that several institutional investors had been “very adamant” that Nicholls should not join Wolseley.
House broker Barclays echoed that view, saying Wolseley had avoided potential “reputational risk” and shareholder questions, which “at the beginning of a new stage would be an unhelpful distraction”.
It praised John Martin, the former finance chief who is due to replace boss Ian Meakins this year, hailing the decision as a “brave step” and “encouraging at the start of his time as CEO”.
Wolseley shares were flat at 4088p.
Martin inherits a much healthier Wolseley thanks to Meakins’ major transformation. During his seven-year tenure as chief executive, Meakins sold off assets and scaled back branches of Bathstore, Plumb Centre and Build Centre chains.